Skip to main content

10 Challenges in Creating an Employee Drug Screening Program

June 7, 2022

Updated December 27, 2023

10 Challenges in Creating a Workplace Drug Testing Programs

Human Resources (HR) departments are responsible for creating employee drug screening programs that are compliant with federal, state, and local regulations. However, navigating the constantly changing regulations can be an incredibly complex task. The legalization of marijuana in some states has made it even more difficult to develop drug screening policies that are compliant with the law. The challenge is to balance the need to maintain a drug-free workplace with the rights of employees.

The complexities of varying regulations can lead to legal troubles for companies that fail to comply with the law. By using a Third-Party Administrator (TPA), such as Vault Workforce Screening, you can ensure you are meeting all compliance requirements no matter where your new hires are located. TPA’s are experts in compliance and can provide guidance on the latest regulations, as well as help create policies that meet the specific needs of a company.

Here are 10 common obstacles when creating a compliant drug and alcohol testing program for employees:

1. Balancing privacy concerns with the need to maintain a safe workplace

Employers are tasked with respecting employee privacy rights while establishing a compliant drug and alcohol screening program. It's crucial to find a balance between fostering a safe and productive work environment and maintaining employee confidentiality. The implementation of the drug testing program should be carefully managed to maintain this balance and uphold employee privacy.

2. Ensuring that the drug testing program is compliant with state, local and federal laws

It's imperative for employers to align their drug testing programs with state, local, and federal legal requirements. The landscape of drug testing is governed by a complex array of laws and regulations and frequent changes, requiring employers to consistently monitor and update their drug policy to remain compliant.

3. Establishing clear procedures and policies for workplace drug and alcohol testing

Employers must develop and document policies and procedures. This includes pre-employment drug testing, rescreening, post-accident drug testing, and random tests. These drug testing policies should clearly specify the situations warranting testing, the type of testing that will be used, and the protocols to follow in the event of a positive test.

4. Maintaining consistency and fairness in drug and alcohol screening

It's crucial for employers to uphold uniformity and fairness in their drug testing processes. This entails applying the same testing procedures to all new hires and employees and interpreting the results with consistent standards.

5. Anticipating and managing false positives and negatives in drug testing

False positives and negatives test results do happen for a variety of reasons, necessitating preemptive planning. Employers need to meticulously develop procedures to address these scenarios, as a lack of preparedness could lead to organizational disruptions and legal vulnerabilities. Establishing a comprehensive and well-structured response strategy is essential to effectively navigate and mitigate potential risks.

6. Promoting employees awareness and understand drug and alcohol testing policies

Employers must actively communicate and clarify their drug testing policy to all employees. Effective communication methods include distributing employee handbooks, conducting training sessions, digital newsletters, and engaging in regular team meetings. These communications methods can help employees understand the company's stance and procedures regarding drug and alcohol screening.

7. Clearly communicating the process and consequences of failing a drug test

Employers have a responsibility to clearly inform their employees about the repercussions of failing a test such as from illicit drugs. This should encompass a detailed explanation of possible disciplinary actions and information about legal implications that may arise. Transparent communication in this area is crucial to ensure employees understand the seriousness of the policy and its potential impact on their employment.

8. Conducting drug tests that is respectful of employee dignity

Employers are obligated to perform drug testing in ways that uphold employee dignity. This involves conducting tests in private settings and ensuring that all procedures are carried out with the utmost respect. Additionally, for non-DOT regulated testing, using an oral fluid drug testing method can be a more humane and less invasive alternative, enhancing employee comfort while maintaining testing efficacy. It's important to note that oral fluid testing is currently not available for DOT-regulated testing.

9. Addressing prescription drug use by employees in the workplace

Navigating prescription drug use among employees is a nuanced and complex aspect of workplace policy. Given that such medications may be essential for an employee’s health, it's important for employers to develop clear policies and procedures. These should thoughtfully balance the necessity of prescription medication for health reasons with workplace safety and productivity considerations.

10. Balancing cost-effectiveness with comprehensive drug testing

While it's important for employers to conduct drug testing cost-effectively, focusing solely on immediate costs might overlook long-term benefits. Expanding drug testing panels, though initially more expensive, can be a prudent investment. Early detection of substance use could prevent accidents, potentially reducing insurance rates and enhancing the company's safety profile. In the long run, this approach not only promotes a safer work environment but can also lead to financial savings by mitigating risks and liabilities.

Vault's comprehensive approach to helping employers overcome drug screening challenges

The obstacles highlighted are common in the realm of drug screening. At Vault Workforce Screening, our expertise extends beyond these challenges, offering a full spectrum of drug screening solutions tailored to businesses of every scale. Our compliance professionals are constantly attuned to the latest regulatory shifts, ensuring that our clients' drug testing policies are not only compliant but also forward-thinking. Beyond compliance, we offer strategic guidance on drug screening best practices, empowering our clients to proactively navigate and stay ahead of evolving trends and regulatory changes in drug screening.

Have a conversation with our Compliance team.

We are currently offering a free 30-minute screening program review with our compliance experts. Schedule today and we'll step through every aspect of your program and where you may be able to improve. There is no obligation or risk involved, and you'll receive a free report you can review with team members following the consultation.


Schedule your free review