Skip to main content

The cost of bad hires and their impact on a business

June 16, 2022

Hiring the right talent is crucial for the success and growth of any organization. However, the consequences of a bad hire can be detrimental, both financially and operationally. Now, more than ever, cost is top-of-mind with nearly every organization. Most have broadened their efforts and are focusing deeper on where they can save costs.  The cost of bad hires, specifically these past three years, has skyrocketed.

According to Zippia, the average cost of a bad hire in 2023 is 30% of that hire’s annual salary.


The Financial Impact:

The financial ramifications of a bad hire extend far beyond the initial recruitment and onboarding expenses. According to recent studies and industry reports, the average cost of a bad hire can range from 30% to 150% of the employee's annual salary. Let's examine some key factors that contribute to these costs:


1. Recruitment Expenses:

When a company hires the wrong person, it often entails going back to the drawing board and restarting the entire recruitment process. This involves spending additional resources on job advertisements, recruiting agencies, pre-employment screenings, background checks, and interviews. The wasted time and money can quickly accumulate, impacting the organization's bottom line.


2. Training and Onboarding:

Investing in new employees' training and onboarding is essential for them to become productive members of the team. However, a bad hire may struggle to meet the required skill level or fail to adapt to the company's culture and processes. Consequently, valuable time and resources are wasted on ineffective training, reducing overall productivity and diverting attention from other critical tasks.


3. Lost Productivity:

A bad hire often leads to decreased productivity and disrupted workflow within the organization. Colleagues and supervisors may need to compensate for the poor performance, resulting in increased workload and stress levels. This not only affects employee morale but also hampers the ability to meet project deadlines and deliver quality work, ultimately impacting the company's reputation and revenue.


4. Termination and Turnover:

If a bad hire's performance remains consistently below par, termination becomes an unfortunate but necessary step. This process incurs additional costs, including severance pay, legal fees, and potential unemployment claims. Moreover, high turnover resulting from bad hires can lead to a constant cycle of recruitment, further increasing expenses and destabilizing team dynamics.


Operational Consequences:

Beyond the financial burden, a bad hire can have severe operational repercussions for businesses:


1. Employee Morale and Engagement:

A poor hiring decision can create a ripple effect, affecting the morale and engagement of existing employees. Co-workers may feel demotivated when they witness subpar performance or have to pick up the slack left by the bad hire. This, in turn, can lead to decreased productivity, increased absenteeism, and higher turnover rates among top-performing employees.


2. Damage to Reputation:

In the age of social media and online reviews, a company's reputation is more important than ever. A bad hire who fails to meet client expectations, delivers substandard work, or engages in unethical behavior can tarnish the organization's image. Negative reviews and word-of-mouth can spread quickly, resulting in lost opportunities and potential clients choosing competitors instead.


3. Cultural Impact:

Hiring the wrong person can disrupt the overall company culture and team dynamics. A toxic employee can create a hostile work environment, leading to interpersonal conflicts and decreased collaboration. This not only affects employee satisfaction but also stifles creativity, innovation, and overall team performance.

In the dynamic and competitive landscape of 2023, companies must recognize the long-term value of investing in the right talent. By avoiding the costly repercussions of a bad hire, organizations can foster a positive work environment, maintain their reputation, and drive sustainable growth and success.


We are currently offering a free 30-minute screening program review with our compliance experts. Schedule today and we'll step through every aspect of your program and where you may be able to improve, as well as how you can successfully add continuous monitoring to your existing program. There is no obligation or risk involved, and you'll receive a free report you can review with team members following the consultation.

Schedule your free review